Court Decision Could Have Impact on Real Estate Market

Photo by Tierra Mallorca on Unsplash

( – A pivotal change may be looming over the American real estate sector due to a recent court decision, as reported by Newsweek. This ruling challenges the conventional commission model where the seller pays the commission that is then split between the seller’s and buyer’s agents. The repercussions of this could be far-reaching, affecting buyers, sellers, and brokers alike, and possibly influencing listing prices.

The core issue centers on a multi-billion-dollar verdict against the National Association of Realtors (NAR) and other key players in the industry. A jury in Missouri found that the established practice, where sellers foot the bill for both buyer and seller agent commissions, artificially elevates home prices and stifles competition. This verdict, if upheld, could result in damages tripling to over $5 billion, affecting about half a million home sellers involved in the class-action lawsuit.

A subsequent nationwide class-action lawsuit has reportedly been initiated against leading real estate firms such as Compass, Redfin, and Douglas Elliman among others. This new legal action aims to cover sellers across the United States and seeks to halt what is estimated to be about $50 billion in inflated commission payments annually.

For sellers, this development could usher in more flexibility in determining how agents are compensated, according to Newsweek. Although this might lead to savings, as they may no longer have to cover the buyer’s agent commission, it could also make agents less inclined to feature their listings. On the buyer’s side, the alteration in the commission model could mean having to pay their agents directly, potentially raising immediate costs but possibly lowering the listing prices of homes.

Brokerage firms are not left untouched. Seller’s agents may need to recalibrate their pricing strategies and service offerings to maintain competitiveness. Buyer’s agents, on the other hand, may find it challenging to prove their worth, especially if buyers start compensating them directly.

The NAR has indicated it will appeal the ruling, emphasizing its commitment to consumer interests and market competition. Conversely, firms like eXp Realty have shown readiness to adapt their business models to whatever changes come their way, citing their “agile” practices.

Copyright 2023,